
The carrier is facing a problem with drivers who frequently abandon their jobs without settling, for example, fines. The company receives fines from Italy, Germany, and France related to speeding by the carrier’s vehicles. Can the company charge the drivers for the amounts of these fines? Can it deduct the costs from their salaries? How much time is there to do this?
Expert response: An employee bears liability when the employer proves (Art. 116 of the Labor Code) the circumstances justifying this liability: a breach of employee duties (Art. 114 of the Labor Code), the employee’s fault (Art. 114 of the Labor Code), the amount of the actual loss (Art. 115 of the Labor Code), and a normal causal link between the employee’s behavior and the resulting loss (Art. 115 of the Labor Code).
Speeding on the road is an offense and can be considered a breach of employee duties by a professional driver. The employee’s fault can be intentional or unintentional. An employee’s unintentional fault may consist of recklessness – when they groundlessly assume they will avoid causing damage – or negligence – when they do not foresee causing damage, even though they could and should have foreseen the occurrence of this effect. The assessment of the groundlessness of the assumption regarding avoiding damage and the possibility of foreseeing it is made taking into account the individual characteristics of the employee. This includes, in particular, their level of education, professional experience, mental development, or age. An employee’s behavior is considered culpable when they can be accused of being able to avoid causing damage in the specific circumstances in which they were performing their work, given their individual characteristics. Damages caused by errors not attributable to the employee are borne by the employer (Art. 117 § 2 of the Labor Code), who should verify the professional and personal qualifications of the employee before hiring them.
In the event of a lawsuit, the employer must demonstrate that the employee was a professional driver, that they were driving the vehicle on that route at the given time, and that they should have known the traffic rules on that route (e.g., due to road signs).
If the drivers are no longer employed, before filing a lawsuit, the employees should first be called upon to pay. Regarding drivers still working for the carrier, according to Art. 87 § 1 of the Labor Code:
§ 1. From the remuneration for work – after deducting social security contributions and personal income tax advances – only the following amounts are subject to deduction:
1) sums enforced under enforcement titles to satisfy maintenance claims;
2) sums enforced under enforcement titles to cover claims other than maintenance claims;
3) cash advances granted to the employee;
4) monetary penalties provided for in Art. 108.
A fine is not an enforcement title; therefore, in the case of making deductions from remuneration for work, the employee’s written consent is required.
In my opinion, it is worth resolving disputes amicably and obtaining statements from the employees. The regulations do not specify mandatory document templates regarding consent for deduction. However, it should be remembered that the document must indicate the amount to be deducted and the title under which the deduction is made. For example:
Employee’s consent to make non-obligatory deductions from remuneration for work
I declare that I consent to the deduction from my remuneration of the amount of …… representing the equivalent of the fine paid by …… imposed on me on …… by …… .
Please deduct the amount of …… in …… installments of …… PLN each, starting from the remuneration for the month of …… .
When making so-called voluntary deductions, it should be remembered that the statement can be withdrawn by the employee at any time without the need for the employer’s consent, and it is necessary to maintain the amount free from deduction.
As for the amount, one can demand a maximum of 3 months’ salary from the employee prior to the damage being caused (receiving the fine). The employee’s three-month salary is calculated according to the rules applicable to determining the cash equivalent for vacation, without taking into account changes in remuneration conditions or the amount of remuneration components introduced after the date the damage was caused. This remuneration is not reduced, when determining the amount of compensation, by deductions and withholdings made from it.
The company’s HR department should calculate the remuneration in accordance with the Regulation of the Minister of Labor and Social Policy of May 29, 1996, on the method of determining remuneration during periods of non-performance of work and remuneration constituting the basis for calculating compensation, severance pay, compensatory allowances to remuneration, and other claims provided for in the Labor Code, and the Regulation of the Minister of Labor and Social Policy of January 8, 1997, on detailed rules for granting vacation leave, determining and paying remuneration for vacation time and the cash equivalent for vacation, and issue a certificate of the driver’s remuneration. The charge should not exceed the calculated amount.
The employer’s claims for compensation for damage caused by an employee as a result of non-performance or improper performance of employee duties are time-barred after 1 year from the day the employer became aware of the damage caused by the employee, but no later than 3 years from the date it was caused. Therefore, it is necessary to first check when the fines arrived. If one year has not passed, calls for payment should be formulated or employees should be asked to submit a statement.
Legal basis:
- Act of June 26, 1974, Labor Code.
- Regulation of the Minister of Labor and Social Policy of May 29, 1996, on the method of determining remuneration during periods of non-performance of work and remuneration constituting the basis for calculating compensation, severance pay, compensatory allowances to remuneration, and other claims provided for in the Labor Code
- Regulation of the Minister of Labor and Social Policy of January 8, 1997, on detailed rules for granting vacation leave, determining and paying remuneration for vacation time and the cash equivalent for vacation
Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-11-06








