
A certain company has received a proposal to transport machinery worth 4 million Euros on a route from France to Poland. The value of the machinery exceeds the company’s insurance coverage, as well as the insurance of most carriers. The company plans to prepare a quote, but wants to have full protection in the event of an unforeseen incident. What insurance will be needed in such a case – carrier’s civil liability (OCP) or cargo insurance?
Expert answer: The scope of protection under carrier’s civil liability (OCP) is limited to the carrier’s fault and does not cover, for example, damages caused by force majeure or damages resulting from the nature of the goods. If the goods are damaged or lost due to the carrier’s fault, they can use the policy.
Cargo insurance in transport protects the interest of the cargo owner in situations where the carrier is not liable for the damage caused. This refers, for example, to acts of force majeure, which can cause serious damage to property. Therefore, it is worth it for the company to have both insurances covering the value of the goods.
However, a number of problems arise here. Firstly, with such a high value, a completely different standard of shipment protection will be expected from the carrier, which means that many more events may be classified as gross negligence. Secondly, with such a value, there is a very small chance of finding an OCP policy that includes gross negligence.
In practice, two solutions are used:
– increasing the guarantee sum for individual transport within the current OCP agreement,
– individual cargo insurance, where the carrier would be the policyholder. In that case, the insurer has no right of recourse against the carrier as the policyholder.
It is worth paying attention to one more aspect. If the company is not going to perform this transport itself, then instead of a contract of carriage, it is worth concluding a forwarding contract, where the freight forwarder is responsible for the proper selection of the carrier, and not for damages incurred during transport. In that case, however, the company must have freight forwarder’s liability insurance (OCS) and a signed forwarding contract, not a contract of carriage. Under the contract, the company should undertake to organize the transport, including insuring the shipment and concluding a contract of carriage on behalf of the client. The remuneration should then include insurance premiums.
Legal basis:
Legal status of the publication (date): 2017-09-17








