
A contractual carrier used the services of a subcontractor who actually performed the transport. Most of the transport operation was carried out correctly, but after unloading, while leaving, the driver damaged goods located in the warehouse. Consequently, the principal issued a debit note for the damaged goods. Is the contractual carrier obliged to compensate for the damage caused by the subcontractor?
Expert response: The nature of the contractual carrier’s (also known as a paper carrier) liability for its subcontractors in international transport is determined by Article 3 of the CMR Convention, according to which “in applying this Convention, the carrier shall be responsible for the acts and omissions of his agents and servants and of any other persons of whose services he makes use for the performance of the carriage, when such agents, servants or other persons are acting within the scope of their employment.” Regarding domestic transport, according to Article 5 of the Transport Law, “The carrier may entrust the performance of transport to other carriers for the entire transport or a part thereof, however, they bear responsibility for their actions as for their own.”
For transport damage to be considered as such, it should arise in connection with the transport, and thus, in principle, occur from the acceptance of the consignment for transport until its delivery (Article 65(1) of the Transport Law; Article 17(1) of the CMR Convention). In the situation presented above, we are not dealing with contractual liability (related to non-performance or improper performance of an obligation) but with tortious liability, and therefore the above provisions do not apply. Tortious liability (ex delicto) is regulated in Articles 415-449 of the Civil Code. Three provisions are of fundamental importance for the entity liable for damage caused by the movement of a motor vehicle: Articles 415, 435, and 436 of the Civil Code. Importantly, the liability provided for in Article 436 of the Civil Code is based on the principle of risk (independent of fault).
Bearing in mind the indicated provisions, the injured party may pursue claims from the entity responsible for the damage (in principle, the owner of the vehicle). Consequently, in the described factual state, the contractual carrier is not the entity that caused the damage, and therefore is not obliged to compensate for it. In such a situation, the injured party should pursue claims directly from the subcontractor.
Legal basis:
- Act of April 23, 1964 – Civil Code
- Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR) and Protocol of signature, done at Geneva on 19 May 1956
- Act of November 15, 1984, Transport Law
Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-07-06








