⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Can freight be deducted for failure to submit documents on time?

Can freight be deducted for failure to submit documents on time?

After completing an international transport service, a certain company was late in delivering the required documents. The freight forwarder threatened to reduce the freight by a previously agreed amount (a potential penalty for missing the deadline was included in the order). However, is reducing the freight due to the failure to deliver documents on time legal?

Expert response: According to the provision in the aforementioned order, “All transport documents (CMR) must be delivered within 14 days of the completion of transport (…). Failure to deliver within this period is subject to a penalty of up to 100 euros, or an extension of the payment term by 60 days.”

A contractual penalty may be stipulated for the breach of any obligation in general or – as in this case – linked to specific instances of non-performance or improper performance of an obligation, provided it is not contrary to the CMR Convention (as this is an international transport case). In legal doctrine, it is accepted that the shaping of a contractual penalty clause is largely left to the will of the parties. Therefore, it may concern specific obligations of the debtor (principal or ancillary), the breach of which will result in a claim for payment of a contractual penalty.

In other words, a contractual penalty may be stipulated for the breach of both the principal obligation and other derivative obligations arising from the contract (see: P. Drapała in “System Prawa Prywatnego” vol. 5, 2nd edition, Warsaw 2013), including, in principle, the late submission of documents.

On the other hand, in light of case law, a contractual penalty must be defined in such a way as to leave no doubt, and its final amount should be determinable independently of any conditions. For this reason, specifying conditions that will affect the amount of the penalty or defining the penalty amount in ranges does not meet the requirement of certainty of the penalty referred to in Article 483 § 1 of the Civil Code. Using expressions such as: up to the amount of the freight, at least 50% of the remuneration, or from 100 to 300 PLN will cause the entire contractual penalty provision to be invalid, and a court may rule that no claims can be pursued based on it.

Although this provision is imprecise (a specific amount should have been indicated rather than a range), it is possible to impose a contractual penalty for failure to deliver documents on time. It is therefore difficult to predict whether a court would consider this clause ineffective. In my opinion, it should.

Please remember that the carrier cannot impose both sanctions. Only one of the penalties may be applied: a monetary penalty or an extension of the payment term. It is impossible to punish twice for the same offense. If your order specifies a deadline for sending documents, you must adhere to it. If it is impossible to meet, you should cross it out and add a different deadline, sending back a scan of the order before accepting it.
However, when you formulate contractual penalty regulations in contracts yourself, remember that the amount of the penalty must be precisely defined.

Legal basis:

Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-05-14