⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Mobbing – how to proceed when an employee reports harassment?

Mobbing - how to proceed when an employee reports harassment?

An employee has reported to the company President several times that they are being mentally harassed and subjected to mobbing. The matter is not clear-cut, as no confirmation of mobbing has been found. Moreover, the employee’s supervisor believes the accusations are groundless. What should be done in such a situation? Can groundless accusations of mobbing serve as grounds for filing a defamation lawsuit against the employee?

Expert response: Before taking action against the employee themselves, the employer should ensure that they have taken all necessary steps to prevent mobbing. However, it seems likely that the employee wants to exercise their right to compensation after terminating the employment contract, based on Article 94(3) § 4 of the Labor Code.

The employer has a statutory obligation to counteract mobbing, which includes:
– preventive measures to ensure that mobbing does not occur in the workplace,
– the obligation to neutralize the phenomenon if it has already occurred,
– the obligation to repair damages if mobbing has caused such damages.

Preventive measures should consist of appropriate regulations included in the work regulations. Internal regulations should be adapted to the needs of an anti-mobbing policy. Another action should be organizing training for employees and management in the area of the mobbing phenomenon itself and the risks associated with it.

Regarding the obligation to neutralize an existing conflict, actions should be taken after receiving information about mobbing. First, the employer should meet with the employee making the accusations. An HR representative should be present at the meeting, and a report should be drawn up and signed by all those present. It is necessary to find out who they are accusing and of what, and what evidence they have to support their claims. Next, the employer should meet with the person accused of mobbing and other witnesses to verify the version of events. These meetings should also take place in the presence of an HR representative, and a report should be drawn up for them as well. Only after gathering evidence can a decision be made regarding further steps.

As for filing a lawsuit against the employee, it would concern the infringement of personal rights. The Civil Code provides that if a personal right is threatened by someone else’s action, the person whose right is protected by law may demand that the action be ceased, unless it is not unlawful. This means that there must be a threat to a right by someone else’s action (this may consist of performing activities that will undoubtedly lead to such an infringement in the future) and the unlawfulness of the action (this behavior must infringe on personal rights, but does not have to be a crime). Numerous court rulings indicate that one can speak of unlawfulness when the behavior of the perpetrator of the infringement of personal rights remains in conflict with the provisions of the act or the principles of social coexistence, and the protection of every person’s personal rights has a scope that can be reconciled with the personal rights of other people.

In court jurisprudence, the prevailing view is that when assessing whether an infringement of a personal right has occurred, the decisive factor is not so much the subjective feeling of the person seeking legal protection, but rather the reaction that the event forming the basis of the claim evokes in society. This means that the infringement of a good name must slander the person in the eyes of other people; that is, if someone deep down does not like a term used towards them that is common, not offensive, and generally indifferent to others, it cannot be concluded that an infringement of a good name has occurred. Because it does not have an objective character, but is merely a subjective feeling.

Furthermore, a lawsuit for the infringement of personal rights can be initiated by the person whose rights have been infringed. In this situation, it seems that if an infringement of a good name has occurred, it would be the person whom the employee is accusing of mobbing, rather than the employer themselves. At least until that information is disseminated externally.

Of course, to prevent this, the employee can be instructed about the consequences of a potential infringement of a good name. In a situation where an infringement of a personal right has already occurred, the victim may demand that the infringer:
1. perform all actions necessary to remove the effects of the infringement,
2. submit a declaration of intent with appropriate content and in a specific form,
3. pay compensation for the infringement of personal rights or transfer an appropriate sum of money to a specified social purpose,
4. repair the property damage resulting from the infringement of personal rights.

Legal basis:

Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-01-08