⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Who is responsible for the so-called “shifting” of goods on pallets during transport?

Who is responsible for the so-called shifting of goods on pallets during transport?

During the international transport of roof tiles, one of the pallets “shifted,” causing damage to the goods carried on it. The driver participated in the loading process. What should be done in such a situation? Who bears the responsibility for the damage, and how can one potentially defend against the contractor’s claims?

Expert answer: The situation described above indicates that the goods were damaged during transport. Since these were roof tiles, the ability to strap the goods is limited due to their fragility and the risk of crushing; therefore, drivers very often secure them too delicately or do not use appropriate tools (mats, wedges, corner protectors) that would help properly secure the load.
Regarding the legal aspect, it would be necessary to determine who was responsible for the proper loading of the shipment.

Since this was an international transport, we should apply the CMR Convention. However, due to the fact that the CMR Convention does not contain regulations in this regard, the Transport Law will apply. According to Article 43 § 1 of the Transport Law, unless the contract or a specific provision states otherwise, loading operations are the responsibility of the sender or the recipient, respectively. In this context, one argument that can be raised is that the loading was not performed correctly, as the goods “shifted during transport” not because of improper securing, but because of improper loading. In practice, there are loading techniques that can prevent such movement of goods during transport (e.g., proper arrangement of pallets, “bracing one pallet against another”).

Despite the lack of explicit regulation, it seems obvious that the carrier is responsible for properly securing the goods. To defend against claims from the contractor, one would need to demonstrate that the goods were properly secured using adequate means (straps, anti-slip mats, corner protectors, etc.). According to Article 17(4), taking into account the provisions of Article 18, paragraphs 2 to 5, the carrier is relieved of liability if the loss or damage to the goods arose from the special risks inherent in one or more of the following causes (enumerated in Article 17(4)(a-f) of the CMR Convention).

Given that the obligation for proper loading lay with the sender, the carrier could invoke:
– Article 17(4)(b) of the CMR Convention – lack or defective condition of packing, if goods, by their nature, are liable to loss or damage when not packed or when packing is defective. The packaging of roof tiles for transport should be appropriate (the goods should be attached to the pallet, not just placed on it, and wrapped in foil so that the whole is suitable for transport – if the roof tiles were not secured in this way, securing the goods against shifting is significantly hindered;
– Article 17(4)(c) of the CMR Convention – handling, loading, stowage, or unloading of the goods by the sender or the consignee, or by persons acting on behalf of the sender or the consignee. Invoking this provision, the carrier could argue that the damage also resulted from improper stowage of the goods on the semi-trailer, as the loader, knowing that the goods have a tendency to shift during transport, should have arranged the pallets so that the goods on them were blocked;
– Article 17(4)(d) of the CMR Convention – the nature of certain kinds of goods which particularly exposes them to total or partial loss or to damage, especially through breakage, rust, decay, desiccation, leakage, normal wastage, or the action of moth or vermin. Invoking this provision, it is also possible to defend the thesis that the carrier is not responsible for the damage, as the fragility of the roof tiles is their natural property and some may simply be damaged, for example, by breaking.

The primary risk arises from the fact that the carrier’s driver participated in the loading, and the court may decide that, due to this circumstance, the possibility of invoking an exemption from liability for damage to the goods due to stowage or loading is excluded. Furthermore, when determining whether the goods were properly secured (taking into account their natural properties), the carrier may face the argument that it required the use of adequate means that could have been foreseen, because they knew what goods would be transported (they accepted an order in which the type of transported goods was indicated).

Legal basis:

  • Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR) and Protocol of Signature, done at Geneva on 19 May 1956.
  • Act of 15 November 1984, Transport Law

Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-01-08