⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Is it possible to cancel an order when the vehicle is already at the loading point?

Is it possible to cancel an order when the vehicle is already at the loading point?

The principal cancelled the transport at the moment the vehicle was at the loading site. The carrier issued an invoice for the full freight amount, which was returned unpaid. Due to the cancellation of the order, the carrier suffered a loss because the vehicle had to complete the route anyway, as half of the refrigerated trailer was intended for another transport where part of the route overlapped. Can the carrier therefore demand coverage of the costs of the cancelled transport?

Expert response: Cancelling a transport order falls within the scope of the right to dispose of the shipment. This right allows the sender to unilaterally change the transport contract or even withdraw from it, both before the shipment is sent and during the transport process. Withdrawal from the contract only requires submitting a relevant statement, which does not even require any justification, and the carrier cannot oppose it in any way. The sender’s exercise of the right to withdraw from the transport contract results in the expiration of the obligation relationship, which means that the transport contract, on the basis of which the carrier positioned the vehicle for loading and even accepted the goods for transport, is considered as not concluded. In other words, upon receiving notice of the order cancellation or a reversal, the carrier is no longer obliged to transport the shipment, while the sender is not obliged to pay the freight.

If the transport order did not provide for contractual penalties for cancelling the order (which was the case in the above situation), the matter must be considered under the provisions of the law.
The provisions of the Civil Code regarding liability for non-performance of an obligation (Art. 471 in conjunction with Art. 361 § 2 of the Civil Code) apply. Unfortunately, they do not allow for equating damage with the amount of the freight. When formulating compensation claims, the carrier would have to calculate the amount of the damage.

To confirm the above, we cite the content of the Supreme Court judgment of December 11, 2007, issued in case II CSK 370/07, according to which: “To assess the validity of a compensation claim for unjustified termination of a contract, it is not sufficient to state how much the injured party would have received if the contract had been performed, but rather what damage they suffered. Full remuneration cannot be equated with lost profit, as it constitutes revenue. Its acquisition is associated with specific costs, expenses, taxes, and other burdens that the injured party would have had to bear, and which they avoided as a result of the termination”.

For this reason, to pursue payment from the principal, it will be necessary to properly demonstrate the amount of damage suffered by the carrier in connection with the order in question. Therefore, one would have to calculate how much the carrier saved by not performing the order in question. That is, from the freight, one should subtract what was saved by not performing this route, calculating the fuel saved and the driver’s salary including contributions that were not paid in connection with the performance of this order, as well as road tolls that were not incurred. When making these calculations, one must take into account the route that the carrier performed (a partial load for the refrigerated trailer was planned). Moreover, the carrier should calculate how much fuel was saved by having half of the refrigerated trailer loaded instead of the whole one, according to the original assumption. In summary, when calculating savings, one must subtract the costs that would have been incurred anyway by performing the order, and one can claim what would have been earned by performing the order.
Calculations should be made, and then a demand for payment should be formulated. It is worth including a legal justification in the demand to try to convince the other party to pay, in order to avoid taking the matter to court. For the future, it is also worth providing for a contractual penalty in the order for cancelling the order, which will cover the costs of positioning the vehicle.

Legal basis:

Legal status of the publication (date): 2017-09-11