What is the carrier’s liability when they delivered an excess shipment to one recipient and a shortage occurred at another?

What is the carrier's liability when they delivered an excess shipment to one recipient and a shortage occurred at another?

As a carrier, we received a claim regarding a missing pallet. This was a domestic transport. We collected two shipments from one sender. After transport to the transshipment terminal, the shipments were to be sent under one consignment note to Gdańsk to company X – 4 pallets, and under a second note to Olsztyn to company Y – 5 pallets. In Gdańsk, the terminal noted the absence of one pallet, and recipient X received only 3 pallets. In Olsztyn, recipient Y received 5 pallets, but one additional pallet for this recipient Y was found at the warehouse in Olsztyn. Ultimately, recipient Y also received this sixth pallet. However, neither recipient admits to having more pallets than they should. The sender has filed a claim for the missing pallet for recipient X in Gdańsk. How should we respond to such a claim?

Expert response: The investigation of the case should begin by verifying the status of the pallets during transshipment, with the drivers, and finally with the recipients. Both orders should also be examined carefully. Orders are the basis of the legal relationship between the sender and the carrier, and consignment notes should only serve as confirmation of what was to be sent according to the orders. Sometimes, so-called packing lists are added to consignment notes, which could help determine where specific pallets were supposed to arrive. The factual situation is likely that recipient Y received 6 pallets, and recipient X only 3 pallets. If it could be established that the pallets were incorrectly labeled by the sender, and the labels on the 6 pallets contained recipient Y’s data, the carrier could be released from liability by citing the sender’s error. The legal classification of the described event is also important. One of the four pallets constituting the shipment did not reach recipient X; therefore, we are dealing with a shortage, not a loss:

Loss of a shipment occurs when, after the transport deadline has passed, the carrier cannot deliver or make available to the recipient at the destination any part of the shipment accepted for transport, and the impossibility results from the cessation of the carrier’s physical control over the shipment. If several items were sent for transport based on one contract and one consignment note, they constitute a single shipment (Art. 35(1)), which means that only the disappearance of all these items can be considered a loss. The absence of one or only some of them must be considered a shortage. [D. Ambrożuk, D. Dąbrowski, K. Wesołowski, Transport Law. Commentary, commentary to Art. 65]

The result of this is that the party entitled to pursue a claim for the shortage is recipient X from Gdańsk, who received the rest of the shipment, not the sender. The sender’s claim without an assignment from recipient X is therefore unfounded. A claim from recipient X would be justified, as from his perspective, it is simply a shortage. If the carrier were to pay compensation to recipient X, they would have a claim for damages against recipient Y, but the success of this claim would require cooperation from the sender in terms of proving the fact and value of the pallet that recipient Y received but should not have.