Missing documentation accompanying goods – who bears the liability

Missing documentation accompanying goods – who bears the liability

A vehicle carrying cargo was stopped because it was not accompanied by the proper documents – in this specific case, it was carrying tobacco, which turned out to be subject to taxation. Additionally, in the remaining cargo space, the carrier was transporting goods from another company. Ultimately, the carrier had to rent a replacement vehicle so that the transport could be delivered to its destination – however, it arrived late. Who will be the proper party in these proceedings and will be liable for damages caused by the lack of appropriate documentation and the delay? The principal (freight forwarding company) or the owner of the goods commissioning the transport to the freight forwarder?

Expert’s answer: Although the carrier received the order not from the owner of the goods but from a freight forwarding company, the freight forwarder, as a party to the contract of carriage, acts in this matter as the sender, within the meaning of the provisions of the CMR Convention.

Under the CMR Convention, the sender is liable to the carrier for all damages that may result from the lack, insufficiency, or irregularity of documents and information, unless there is fault on the part of the carrier (Art. 11(2) of the CMR Convention). Pursuant to the provision of Art. 11(1) of the CMR Convention, in order to complete customs or other formalities that must be fulfilled before the delivery of the goods, the sender should attach the necessary documents to the consignment note or place them at the carrier’s disposal and provide them with all requested information. It is emphasized in legal doctrine that this does not only refer to information requested by the carrier, but to all information necessary to complete the formalities. The sender is liable to the carrier for all damages that may result from the lack, insufficiency, or irregularity of these documents and information, unless there is fault on the part of the carrier (Art. 11(2) of the CMR Convention). The liability of the sender to the carrier for damages resulting from the lack of documents and information regulated by this provision is a very strict liability. The sender can only be released from this liability if they prove that the irregularities referred to in the provision were caused by the fault of the carrier.

Importantly, the carrier must prove that they have suffered damage, the amount of that damage, and that it arose in connection with incorrect information provided by the freight forwarding company as the sender. For the freight forwarder to be held liable, the following conditions must be met:

– damage must occur, the amount of which must be proven (e.g., a fine in connection with this transport, payment for forced parking, costs of providing another vehicle, fuel costs, costs of additional driver’s salary, costs incurred in connection with the delay, etc.)

– it must be proven that the damage occurred as a result of incorrect information provided by the freight forwarder, so it must be shown that it was the lack of information about the properties of the goods that caused the damage and the stopping of the vehicle. This should result from the fine or documentation received from the services that stopped the vehicle.