
A shipment from Gdańsk containing ordered components for one of the machines arrived at the recipient. Before installing the sent part, it turned out that the packaging in which the shipment arrived was torn. At the same time, the ordered part was damaged. After talking to the employees, it turned out that the person responsible for receiving such shipments made a mistake and did not check the condition of the ordered goods when receiving the shipment from the courier. Is it still possible to obtain compensation in this situation?
Expert answer: Although there are not many details in the question, it is possible to try to answer it even based on such information. It can be assumed that since the indicated machine part was ordered from Gdańsk, the provisions of the Act of November 15, 1984, Transport Law will apply in the case in question. It must be clearly stated that, in practice, a thorough inspection of the shipment is one of the basic duties of the person responsible for these matters in a given company. According to the provisions of the Transport Law, the acceptance of a shipment by an authorized employee without reservations results in the expiration of the right to compensation for damage to the transported goods. However, there are significant exceptions to this rule. Accepting goods without reservations will provide an opportunity to claim compensation if:
1) the damage was stated in a protocol before the shipment was accepted by the authorized person;
2) such a statement was omitted due to the carrier’s fault;
3) the loss or damage resulted from the carrier’s willful misconduct or gross negligence;
4) the authorized person discovered damage that could not be noticed from the outside after accepting the shipment and, within 7 days, requested that its condition be determined and proved that the damage occurred between the time the shipment was accepted for transport and its delivery.
The described situation suggests that it is almost certain that the first and last points will not be applicable. Unfortunately, proving that the failure to state the damage in a protocol was the carrier’s fault or that the damage resulted from the carrier’s willful misconduct or gross negligence may also prove impossible. It must be remembered that the burden of proving that the above-mentioned circumstances occurred lies with the recipient of the shipment, as they are the one who wants to base specific legal effects (claiming compensation) on this.
- Legal basis: Art. 76 of the Act of November 15, 1984, Transport Law
- Legal status of the publication (date): 2016-06-06








