⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Does the carrier choose the shipment route themselves?

Does the carrier choose the shipment route themselves?

A certain transport company has been operating between Silesia and Gdynia for years along a fixed, fastest route, while avoiding low-quality roads that could cause damage to the vehicles. One of the company’s clients requested that the drivers take different routes, determined by the client. Does the client have the right to do this?


Expert answer: The issue of the route by which a shipment is transported is regulated by the provisions of the Act of November 15, 1984, Transport Law. This document (Art. 46, paragraph 1) indicates that the route for the shipment is determined by the carrier, taking into account the sender’s requests as far as possible. Although the cited provision is very general, it should be understood to mean that the carrier should fulfill the request to transport goods via a route chosen by the sender if there are appropriate possibilities for performing the transport. The impossibility of transporting a shipment via a route indicated by the sender can be spoken of when, for example, the means of transport used for the shipment cannot travel along that road, or using the road would require incurring economically unjustified expenses or would cause an excessive extension of the transport time.
Applying the indicated regulations to the situation described in the question, it must be stated that the client has the right to choose the route. However, it must be carefully checked whether transport via the route chosen by the client is possible at all. For example, if the client designates a route that leads through a bridge that only vehicles up to 3.5 tons can cross, and the shipment is being delivered by a heavier vehicle, the carrier should refuse to travel that route. Every time the transport route is determined by the sender, the carrier has an obligation to carefully check such a route. Any oversights in this regard may prove unfavorable for the carrier.
A carrier who agrees on a route with the sender should keep their legitimate interests in mind. Ultimately, in discussions with the sender, the carrier should argue their position with economically unjustified financial outlays or unnecessary extension of the transport time.