⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Loss in container weight

Loss in container weight

A client has accused a transport company of the disappearance of 500 kg of used clothing that was supposed to be transported in a container. However, the container was sealed by the client and the seals were not tampered with. Is there a risk that the carrier will have to pay a penalty to the client?


Expert answer: Although the question lacks many details, it can be assumed that under normal conditions, the carrier should not be held liable. The answer to the question can be found in the Act of 15 November 1984, Transport Law. According to the provisions of the Act (Art. 66 sec. 2), the carrier is not liable for losses in the weight of a container if three conditions are met simultaneously:

  1. the container was closed by the sender;
  2. the seals were applied by the sender themselves;
  3. the condition of the container, as well as the condition of the seals at the time of delivery of the shipment to the recipient, is not compromised.

The first two conditions do not require comment. As for the third, it is worth adding that the requirement of integrity refers to the container, not its contents. This is related to the nature of the container, which in this case is treated as a type of packaging. If all three conditions are met, it is considered that the damage did not occur during transport, and therefore the carrier is not liable for it. Of course, even in such a situation, the client may try to prove that one (or more) of the conditions described above was not met. However, they would then have to prove it themselves, which may turn out to be a very difficult task.