⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

How to be released from liability for fault in the selection of a carrier?

How to be released from liability for fault in the selection of a carrier?

Factual background: We are a small freight forwarding company based in the Masovian Voivodeship. Recently, following the theft of a vehicle with cargo, we received a notice from a client regarding claims against us in connection with the improper selection of a transport company.

How can we be released from liability for fault in the selection of a carrier?


Expert answer: Article 799 of the Civil Code states that a freight forwarder is responsible for carriers and further freight forwarders they use to execute an order, unless they are not at fault in the selection. This provision is the basis for directing claims against freight forwarders who unreliably verify and select carriers authorized to perform transport. The burden of proof, i.e., the obligation to prove the lack of fault in selection, lies with the freight forwarder in such a case. The provisions of the Civil Code do not specify how one can be released from liability in this regard. However, following the case law of common courts, it should be noted that a freight forwarder must demonstrate due diligence in the selection of a carrier. The Supreme Court in its judgment of January 27, 2004, file ref. no. II CK 389/02, stated that “Due diligence of a freight forwarder within the meaning of Art. 355 of the Civil Code in connection with Art. 799 of the Civil Code is maintained if they demonstrate that they entrusted specific transport services to a carrier whose professionalism and quality of services provided inspired trust.” Merely conducting business in a specific industry is not a basis for concluding that such an entity ensures the performance of an obligation. For this reason, checking KRS data or a carrier’s insurance policy cannot be considered decisive. What counts in this regard is solely knowledge about the carrier’s way of conducting business. The catalog of a freight forwarder’s actions is not closed or specified by legal provisions or court rulings. No standard of actions taken by freight forwarders has been developed that would result in being released from liability in the event of damage. Undoubtedly, however, they should be guided by common sense and their experience, as well as demonstrate inquisitiveness regarding the claims history of a given carrier.

In the given case, the freight forwarder should demonstrate knowledge about any previous thefts, the carrier’s experience related to the transport of a given type, and show that they made every effort to verify the company to which they entrusted the transport.