⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Can a driver’s license be confiscated due to suspicion of causing a traffic collision?

Can a driver's license be confiscated due to suspicion of causing a traffic collision?

Factual background: A car driver was involved in a traffic collision. The Police were called to the scene. After conducting on-site procedures, the Police established a suspicion that the driver was the perpetrator of the accident, which resulted in the confiscation of the driver’s license against a receipt issued by the Police.

In such a situation, did the Police have the authority to confiscate the driver’s license, and can the car driver continue to drive the vehicle?


Expert response: According to the current Road Traffic Act of June 20, 1997, the Police may confiscate a driver’s license against a receipt in the event of a reasonable suspicion that the driver has committed a crime or an offense for which a driving ban may be imposed (Art. 135, item 1, clause 2). The above provision does not mandate the obligatory confiscation of a driver’s license, but grants the Police the authority to do so. Furthermore, the aforementioned provision contains a general rule indicating that the confiscation of a driver’s license can only take place when there is a suspicion of a crime or offense for which a driving ban may be imposed. For example, one can point to Article 86 of the Code of Petty Offenses, which states:

§ 1. Whoever, by failing to exercise due caution, causes a threat to road traffic safety, is subject to a fine.
§ 2. Whoever commits the offense specified in § 1 while under the influence of alcohol or a similarly acting substance is subject to the penalty of arrest, restriction of liberty, or a fine.
§ 3. In the event of the commission of the offense specified in § 1 by a person operating a vehicle, a driving ban may be imposed.

Thus, even for the suspicion of committing an offense consisting of failure to exercise due caution and causing a threat to road traffic safety, a driving ban may be imposed. It should be noted that in the case of license confiscation, the Police issue a receipt. The received receipt entitles the holder to drive a vehicle for 7 days. Subsequently, within 7 days, the Police forward the confiscated license to the appropriate Court, which issues a decision on the confiscation or return of the license. The Court has 14 days to take the aforementioned action. An appeal may be filed against the decision to confiscate the license.

As follows from the above, the driver has the right to operate vehicles only within 7 days from the date of obtaining the receipt. A problem arises when the aforementioned period expires, as the legal provisions do not explicitly define the driver’s situation in such a case. The answer to this question is not unambiguous. It should be emphasized that until a final decision on the confiscation of the license is made, the driver (against whom there are reasonable suspicions of being the perpetrator of a crime or offense) should be considered a person who holds driving privileges. However, during a traffic stop, they are physically unable to present the aforementioned document because it was confiscated by the Police against a receipt. Thus, by driving a car in such a case, they potentially commit an offense under Article 95 of the Code of Petty Offenses: “Whoever operates a vehicle on a public road, in a residential zone, or in a traffic zone without having the required documents with them is subject to a fine of up to 250 PLN or a reprimand.”