Methods of evaluating and selecting suppliers in an enterprise – a case study – part 4

Methods of evaluating and selecting suppliers in an enterprise - a case study - part 4

Methods of evaluating and selecting suppliers in an enterprise – a case study – part 1

Methods of evaluating and selecting suppliers in an enterprise – a case study – part 2

Methods of evaluating and selecting suppliers in an enterprise – a case study – part 3

In turn, Table 4 (“Logistyka” No. 5/2012, p. 23 – ed. note) presents the results for the studied method of supplier evaluation and selection. The methods used, through the diversity and complexity of the calculation method, provide highly reliable results.

As can be seen in Table 4, different results were obtained by establishing two scoring variants. Different results were also obtained in the arithmetic mean method and the weighted average method. With the first scoring method, supplier E obtained the highest arithmetic mean, while supplier D obtained the lowest; with the weighted average, supplier D was also ranked lowest, but the best result did not go to supplier E, but to supplier C. With the second scoring method, supplier E also obtained the highest arithmetic mean, while supplier F obtained the lowest; however, the lowest weighted average went to supplier D, and the highest to supplier E.

Furthermore, a graphical method was used, consisting of presenting qualified suppliers on a radar chart, where the strengths and weaknesses of each of them were shown in a transparent manner. Figures 7 and 8 show a comparison of the results for 4 selected suppliers according to the adopted type of scoring. The values on the chart increase along the radius, at the center of the circle they take the value 0, while on the circumference they take the value 5. Connecting the points reflecting the ratings assigned to each supplier creates a geometric model characterizing the supplier. The ideal state is a circle-shaped model.

Comparing the two best suppliers allows for an assessment of which supplier is better than the other in terms of a given criterion (Figure 7). Supplier E outperforms supplier C in terms of: transport costs – 4, number of reported complaints – 6, inventory maintenance – 4, and potential – 4. In turn, supplier C offers a more favorable price level – 6, a longer delivery credit period – 6, and a shorter order fulfillment time – 4, therefore it is better in issues that are of great importance to the enterprise. Therefore, even though supplier E received the highest arithmetic mean, it was not the highest in the ranking according to the weighted average.
Similarly, one can conclude by looking at the two weakest suppliers. Despite the fact that both suppliers received the same number of points, supplier D received the lowest rating calculated according to the weighted average. This fact is explained by the circular model (Figure 7), which shows that it received higher ratings in categories of little importance to the enterprise (inventory maintenance – 4 and potential – 4), while low ratings in very important issues (price level – 2, delivery credit – 0).
With the second scoring method, the ideal supplier is represented by a circle with a radius of 5 points, as this is the highest rating in each category. Analyzing the circular model created in this scoring system (Figure 8), it can be stated that supplier E indeed shows the largest range and a course most similar to a circle. It is more difficult, however, to indicate the supplier with the smallest range. Looking at the chart (Figure 8), it can be concluded that the proportions between the best and the weakest supplier are smaller than in scoring system I.

The article comes from the magazine “Logistyka” 6/2012.

L2012-6s12.pdf