Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 2

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise - a case study - part 2

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 1

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 3

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 4

Another perspective was also proposed in work [18]. The author focuses here on discussing seven methodologies for supplier evaluation and selection:

  • Bespoke Approach (BA)
  • Multi-Attribute Analysis (MAA)
  • Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT)
  • Multiple Regression (MR)
  • Cluster Analysis (CA)
  • Fuzzy set theory (FST)
  • Discriminant analysis (DMA).

The classification of supplier evaluation and selection methods proposed in work [39] is developed in [28]. The author reviews the literature from the period 1974 – 2000 and supplements the division of methods with a group of Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) models. Furthermore, the author proposes a different classification of supplier evaluation and selection methods, distinguishing works:

  • depending on the adopted procurement strategy (single sourcing vs. multi sourcing)
  • implementing procurement with or without order allocation (sourcing with or no order allocation)
  • considering or not considering inventory control (inventory management models).

In the next work [9], the authors conducted a very broad literature review of the studied issue and classified supplier evaluation and selection methods, distinguishing 5 groups of methods, supplementing the classification proposed in [28] with models based on the use of Artificial intelligence (Artificial intelligence based models). At the same time, in their literature review concerning methods supporting the decision-making process in the area of supplier evaluation and selection, the authors develop, among others, works [18, 39]. However, they point out that earlier works concerning the literature review of the issue focused on models used in the last phase of the supplier evaluation and selection process – the final selection phase. In their review, they expanded the topic to include an analysis of methods used in the remaining phases of this process (consistent with Figure 3). Also worthy of special attention is the second plane of division of supplier evaluation and selection methods used in the discussed work. The classification focused on the choice of supplier selection method depending on the adopted purchasing strategy, in relation to the Kraljic portfolio matrix [24].

Another work in which the author classifies supplier evaluation and selection methods in relation to the phases of the supplier selection process is [34]. The author classifies supplier evaluation and selection methods, published in 147 works from the period 1985 – 2005, into 3 groups: evaluation criteria selection models, supplier selection models, and supplier-buyer relationship models.

The article comes from the journal “Logistyka” 4/2012.

L2012-4s34.pdf